Now Serving Beer and Wine

Now Available

Beer and Wine

For In-House Dining

Gourmet, Hand-Tossed, New York Style Pizza

New York Slice Company is a New York Style Pizza joint in Sarasota, Florida. Family owned and operated, N.Y. Slice Co. offers gourmet, hand-tossed, New York style pizzas, Strombolis, and Calzones. We keep a hot slice cabinet stocked with 3 different pizza flavors for pizza-by-the-slice. Our full menu offers a wide selection of pasta dinners, salads, appetizers, and desserts.

As our name suggests, the pizza slice is the name of the game. We keep a hot pizza cabinet stocked with  huge, 20 inch pizza pies for pizza-by-the-slice. In addition to the ever popular plain cheese and pepperoni pizzas, we make a different specialty pizza every day. And if you’re in the mood for something different, we’ll let you create-your-own slice with up to 3 toppings on a slice of plain cheese.

First Responders & Teachers

First responders and public school teachers recieve at standing 10% discount on all regularly priced menu items

Read Details

New Hours
closed on Mondays
Tue – Sat: 12 PM – 8 PM

Classic Cheese Pizza

Slice Special All Day, Every Day

2 Slices and a Drink

All Day, Every Day!
Dine in or Carry Out.

Choose 2 slices from our pizza cabinet and 1 drink from an assortment of canned soda, bottled water, or juice for the kids.

The $4.95 price includes tax too!

Garden Special All Day, Every Day

1 Lunch Salad
1 Pizza Slice
1 Drink