Hand-Tossed, New York Style Pizza

All of our pizzas, calzones, and strombolis are made with hand-tossed, New York style crusts which are cooked to a traditional deep, rich brown with some black spotting.

View Our Specialty and Gourmet Pizzas.

Delicious, Cheesy Bread Twists

Hand-Tossed pizza crust cut into quarters and rolled up with mozzarella and romano cheeses, garlic, oregano, and evoo. Baked to perfection and served with marinara.

View All of Our Delicious Appetizers.

Salads Made Fresh When You Order

Every salad that we serve is made at the time you order it using vegetables that were prepared that day. You can taste the difference.

View Our Specialty Salads.

Dining Room Now Open!!
Come Dine With Us.

New York Slice Co. is thrilled to re-open our dining room and welcome our guests to dine in. We will still provide our delivery and curb-side pickup, but if you’re out and about and want a quick bite in a comfortable and safe atmosphere, stop on in for a slice, stromboli, salad, or any of our other delicious menu items.

Monday through Saturday from 12pm til 8pm
Curb-Side Pickup and Delivery Only

From all of us here at New York Slice Company, thank your for your continued support and please stay safe.

New York Style Pizza

New York Style Pizza, SarasotaNew York Slice Company is a New York Style Pizza joint in Sarasota, Florida. Family owned and operated, N.Y. Slice Co. offers gourmet, hand-tossed, New York style pizzas, Strombolis, and Calzones. We keep a hot slice cabinet stocked with 3 different pizza flavors for pizza-by-the-slice. Our full menu offers a wide selection of pasta dinners, salads, appetizers, and desserts.

Every Friday & Saturday

All Day, Every Day

2 Slices Of Pizza Lunch Sarasota

All Day, Every Day

Pizza and Salad Lunch Special Sarasota

High Quality, Great Value, Daily Specials

At New York Slice Co., we take great pride in offering superior, gourmet products at deliciously affordable prices. Our daily and weekly specials give our guests the best value on great food. Whether it’s 2 slices and a 16oz drink for $4.95 everyday, or our Pasta Dinner BOGO on Wednesdays, we offer scrumptious deals every day of the week… (except Sundays… we’re closed 🙂 )

Made In-House

While many pizzerias order gluten-free crusts that are pre-made and shipped, New York Slice Co. makes their G.F. crusts in-house. Owner and head pizzaiolo Brad Rudy experimented with many different ingredients and combinations until he came up with a gluten-free crust recipe (secret) that is second to none: crispy, flavorful, and substantial!

Weekly Specials

Every Tuesday

Tuesday, FREE Appetizer.* Get a free appetizer when you purchase a stromboli, calzone, or large specialy, gourmet, or create-your-own pizza. Choose from Twists, Stuffed Mushrooms, or Garlic Bread.

Every Wednesday

Wednesday, Pasta BoGo.*  Buy one of 5 select pasta dinners at regular price and get one for FREE. Includes a freshly made side salad and garlic bread.

Every Thursday

Thursday, 3 for Thursday.*  ALL DAY EVERY THURSDAY.  Get a large, 3 topping pizza, 1 appetizer, and a 2 liter of soda for only $20.00.

*Some limitations apply. Cannot be combined with any other discount or special offer. Please call store with any questions.